This by far was our families favorite island. It was indeed the most beautiful water of all of our day island trips we did. Lunch was good. The water and sand on the west side of the island were soft. Black tipped small sharks swam around us and were really fun to see. Our family of 4 adults would probably skip this tour in the future, however due solely to the boat ride to and from the island. The other day trips we went on to other islands and not Robinson Caruso used higher speed catamarans to and from the port. This group used a catamaran, but once we left the port past the "no wake zone" speed, we literally didn't change speeds, we slowly motored to the island, which took us about 1 1/2 hours to get to the island, which was about the same distance as the other islands we toured days before, and those took 30-45min. For us, this was a drawback as it lent to more motion sickness on the boat, and more time on the boat round trip and less time on the island. We felt we had just arrived at the island when it was time to go back. We unfortunately opted to hire a speed boat ($$$) back to to port vs taking the already paid excursion transport. But we didn't get motion sick in the high speed boat and was back in 25min. If this excursion had a higher speed option to/from the island, we'd do it again in a heartbeat, but unfortunately the slow transport wasn't a good thing for us. Other than that, the island was simply wonderful!!!